http://www.ted.com/talks/jared_diamond_on_why_societies_collapse?language=enhttp://www.ted.com/talks/jared_diamond_on_why_societies_collapse?language=en
Click on the link and watch the video or copy and paste in the URL, then answer the following questions.
1. To what extent does Montana pass or fail Jared Diamond's 5 point framework? Explain using evidence from the talk.
2. According to Jared Diamond what is the first common thread that emerges from the collapses of past and present societies. Provide specific examples from the talk.
3. What are the similarities between collapses and bacteria in a petri dish?
4. According to Jared Diamond what is the second common thread that emerges from the collapses of past and present societies. Provide specific examples from the talk.
5. According to Jared Diamond what is the third common thread that emerges from the collapses of past and present societies. Provide specific examples from the talk.
6. According to Jared Diamond what generalizations create a blueprint for trouble. Explain and provide examples.
7. Identify 5 ticking time bombs we face today?
8. According to Jared Diamond, what is the most important thing we need to do to avoid a collapse. Do you agree or disagree? Defend your position with 3 reasons.
9. Why is a non-sustainable course a dangerous one. Explain .
10. Is Jared Diamond hopeful for the future or doubtful. Take a position and support using evidence from his talk.
1- Human environmental impact, toxic problems from mines waste, caused damage in billions of damage, weeds control, 200 mil. a year, forest management, forest fires, climate change friendly trade neighbors, hostile neighbors.
ReplyDelete2- The repeatability of collapse after a society reaches its peak. After the society gets rich and good they collapse after.
3- A mismatch between available resources and resource consumption or economic out plays and economic potential, in a petri dish bacteria grows generations pass and the petri dish degrades.
4- The second common trend that emerges is there are many environment factors that make some societies for fragile than others.
5- The3 third and final trend is that civilizations did not realize what they were doing.
6- There is a conflict of interest between the short term of the decision making elites and long term interest of the society as a whole which are able to insulate themselves from whats going to happen.
7- The time bombs are water, soil, climate change, invasive species and population problems.
8- We need to solve our problems of water and soil and population but not toxins we would be in trouble.
9- It can not be maintained and the outcome wouldn't be solve until a few decades.
10- I think that Jared Diamond is hopeful from the future because he knows what hes saying and how we can prevent things that are happening, we just need more people e to listen to him and especially the government need to listen to him be he can help us avoid a collapse.
~~~~~~~~~~~~Alex Beetan~~~~~~~~~~~~
1- Human environmental impact, toxic problems from mines and a lot of damages that occur to the environments.example (climate change).
ReplyDelete2.collapse after a society reaches its peak. when people gather there money,that intends to lead to a good thing.but that could led to a collapse.
3. The similarities between both are available resources economic out plays and
In a petri dish bacteria grows generation pass.
4.The second common trend that emerges is where many environments make factors that makes societies.
5.The third final trend is that many civilizations wasnt thinking on what they was basically doing.
6. generalizations created a blueprint for trouble because there were a lot of decisions between those generalizations short term making decisions.
7.The time bombs we are facing today are water and soil and climate changes.including
Population problems.
8.We need to help our problems by gathering water and soil and to help our population.
9.It can not and would not be maintained until a few years.
10. Yeas i do think hes helpful because he's explains in details that the environmental problems should be protected and good enough for the future to become and better future.we as a nation she listen to him because of his good ted talks videos he has put up to let people know that the world needs to become a better place in order to make the future a better place for the future.i do agree with him because we should listen to what he says,it would help the people understand the good talks he had given us.
1- He had failed the 5 points because of all the bad things that had happen such as Forest Fires, Climate Change, Mines, and Human harm
ReplyDelete2- The first common thread of collapse is at its all time high they are know to collapse
3- Similarities between the collapse was that They both got mixed up with there resources and there economic situation was a mess
4- The second common thing that they had in common was they had many problems with the environment.
5- The third common trend was that they didnt realize how much harm they were doing
6- The blue print for trouble is the short term and the long term and seeing what is going to happen to them
7- 5 Ticking time bombs are soil,water,climate change, pollution and invasive species
8- We need to have all the right resources and enough of it so we dont run out of it and we have extra to prevent us from failing
9- Its dangerous because of the time that it would take to solve all of the problems
10- He is hopeful for the future because what he is planning sounds like a plan that will not fail , its a plan that if we continue to use in the right way its very rare that we can fail.
1. he failed the 5 points because of climate change, human environmental impact and toxic problems
ReplyDelete2. the first threat to happen towards collapse is trying to expand
3. the similarities between collapse and bacteria is that is always a problem in nations
4. the second common threat towards collapse is environmental problems
5. the third common threat is civilization not realizing what there doing wrong
6. creating a blueprint is know what you doing, know what you are using, finally know who's doing what. For example building a house each person in charge on what they do, also know the tools they working with and know how its gonna look like in the end
7. the 5 ticking bombs we facing are limited resources, climate change, overpopulation, hostile neighbors and natural disasters
8. important things we need for us not to have a collapse is learn to use resources, have a backup plan, strong government, good trading partners. i do agree. one reason is we have a backup plan if something goes wrong, another reason is we have a strong government so if something goes wrong they will help, finally is we good trading partners to help us with things we need
9. its dangerous because if it goes wrong our nation might have problems
10. Jared diamond is hopeful because he is showing what we are doing wrong
1. Montana failed Jared Diamond's 5 point framework because they are have environmental damage, climate change, terrorist attacks and most of the income is outside Montana.
ReplyDelete2. According Jared Diamond the first common thread that emerges from the collapses of past and present societies is after their peaks because resources and economics.
3. The similarities between collapses and bacteria in a petri dish mismatch between resources and consumption. Bacteria dish grows and doubles the size and keeps doubling until the highest it dies.
4. According to Jared Diamond, the second common thread that emerges from the collapses of past and present societies is environmental factors. Like latitude, nutrients, water and rainfall.
5. According to Jared Diamond, the third common thread that emerges from the collapses of past and present societies was to not tackle the problems and if we did not solving it.
6. According to Jared Diamond generalizations that create a blueprint for trouble are the government trying to solve the problem and the people.
7. 5 ticking time bombs we face today are water, soil, population problems, climate change and toxics.
8. According to Jared Diamond, most important thing we need to do to avoid a collapse is to forget that there is 1 most important thing to solve. We need to solve all our problems equally because 1 problem not being solved can lead to a collapse.
9. Non-sustainable course is a dangerous one because it will be solved by war.
10. Jared Diamond is doubtful for the future because he is trying to tell everyone that the Philippines is going to lose its forest in 5 years and the Solomon’s are going to lose their forest in a year. He is saying that we will be in trouble if we don’t fix one problem we will collapse.
1. Deforestation, climate change, mines, human harm.
ReplyDelete2. The first common thread of a collapse is that a society thinks they're invincible.
3. The similarities are the the problems spread quickly without a solution.
4. The second common thread of a collapse is environmental problems.
5. The third thread is that the people don't know how much harm they do to themselves.
6. The blueprint is like a prediction of what will happen in their future.
7. 5 ticking bombs we deal with today are water, soil, climate change, deforestation, and toxics.
8. We need to even out our problems and solve them almost simultaneously because if we don't there won't be a balance and that will lead to worse problems.
9. Non-sustainable course is dangerous because it's solved by wars.
10. Jared diamond is doubtful for the future because he sees all the problems we have today and he doesn't think we are worried enough to solve them which will lead to our collapse.
1. its Deforestation, climate change, mines, human harm.
ReplyDelete2. that a society thinks they're invincible.
3. the problems spread quickly without a solution.
4. second common thread of a collapse is environmental problems.
5. third thread is that the people don't know how much harm they do to themselves.
6. The blueprint is like a prediction of what will happen in their future.
7. the five ticking bombs we deal with today are water, soil, climate change, deforestation, and toxics.
8. We need to even out our problems and solve them almost stimulations because if we don't there won't be a balance and that will lead to worse problems.
9. its not steady course is dangerous because it's solved by wars.
10. Jared diamond is doubtful for the future because he sees all the problems we have today and he doesn't think we are worried enough to solve them which will lead to our collapse however the fact that he is forgetting is that we always rise up and overcome all challenges that come our way.
-Bryannah Jeudy
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDelete
ReplyDelete1.)he failed the five points because of all the damages such as chill mate change and fires.
2.)they are known to collapse.
3.)the similarities are they both had messed up there resources .
4.)the second common thread they had was the damages.
5.)the third common thread was everything was getting out of hand they did not realize what they where doing.
6.)government trying to solve problems.
7.)soil,water and climate change.
8.)we should always be prepared.
9.)it's dangerous because it will be solved by problems.
10.)he is very helpful because he is trying very hard so nothing collapse.
Climate change^*
Delete1- Montana fails all of Jared Diamond's 5 point frameworks which were: ~Human Environmental Impacts: toxic problems from mine waste, weeds we control, lost agricultural area salinization and forest fires. ~Climate Change: Montana is getting warmer and dryer, irrigation agriculture. ~Relation with Friendly's: Montana's income is dried from outer state, making it vulnerable.
ReplyDelete~Hostile Neighbors: hostiles overseas are affecting oil supply and terrorist attacks.
~Political, Economic, Social Cultural: Montana has long held values which seems to be getting in their way today, long held devotions and had no government regulation.
2- According to Jared Diamond, the first common thread that emerges from the collapses of past and present societies is the repetition of a collapse after a society reaches it's peak. There are many societies that don't wind down gradually but they build up richer and more powerful. After, within a few decades after that peak, they collapse.
3- The similarities between collapses and bacteria in a petri dish is that they both had a mismatch between available or unavailable resources and economic out plays or economic potential.
4- According to Jared Diamond, the second common thread that emerges from the collapses of past and present societies is that there are many often environmental factors that make some societies more fragile than others and many of those factors are not often understood. One example is that Eastern Island ended up as the most devastating case of complete deforestation.
5- According to Jared Diamond, the third common thread that emerges from the collapses of past and present societies is that the civilizations did not know what they were doing and they did not perceive the impacts on the environment or stopped it in time.
6- According to Jared Diamond, the generalizations that create a blueprint for trouble are: a conflict of interest between the short term interest of the decision making elites and the long term interest of the society as a whole.
7- 6 ticking time bombs we face today are:
~ water ~ invasive species
~ soil ~ photosynthetic ceiling
~ climate change ~ population problems; etc.
8- According to Jared Diamond, the most important thing we need to do to avoid a collapse is to forget about there being any single thing that is the most important thing we need to do. One example is if we solve our problems of water, soil and population but don't solve our problems of toxins then we are in major trouble.
9- A non-sustainable course is a dangerous one because it cannot be maintained and the outcome is going to get resolved within a few decades. This means that those of us who are are less than 50 or 60 years old will see how these paradoxes are resolved and those of us over the age of 60 will not be able to see the resolution, but our children and grandchildren currently will.
10- I think Jared Diamond is doubtful for the future because he views the problems that we are facing today realizing that we aren't doing what were supposed to be doing, knowing that they are problems based on our own decision making but they are also not beyond our control.
~ Jocelyne Morales
1.Montana fails Jared Diamond's 5 point framework , toxic problems and forest management.
ReplyDelete2.The first common thread was they think they are successful.
3.They both are similar because they both create problems.
4.the second common thread is environmental problems.
5.the third common thread was their thinking.
6. The generalization that create blueprint for trouble was their hard time for decision mAking.
7.Water,soil,climate change,population issues and species.
8. I disagree because once if collapse happens everything gets damage and we can fix it if we work hard by getting together.
9. Because it takes time to sove problems and sometimes it doesn't work.
10.He's a doubtful because not every time a persons thinking toward anything.
1. Montana fails jared diamonds frame work because of the income coming from outside of the state has been dried. The waste from mines, waste, weeds and the lost of forest from fires. Terroist from overseas are affecting the oil supply and terroist attacks, fused with an already poisioned atmosphere and sad social culture that wont change and no government regulation.
ReplyDelete2. The common thread that emergers from collapses of the past are a cycle of the civlization reaching it's peak then falling from there on out. They build richer and stronger but eventually fall.
3. The similarities between collapses and bacteria in a petri dish is they mismatch and don't belong. Unavalbile resources economic problems.
4. Many environmental factors contribute to the collapse of nations, it;s the second common thread brought up for example the eastern island and it's use of the tress.
5. The third common thread that emerges from the collapses of the past and present socieites is the lack of foresight for actions commited. Not seeing the long term cause of their actions.
6. Jareds blueprint for collapse is that a conflic of interest between short term and the long term of the societies health
7. Ticking time bombs we face Water pollution0- invasive species-photosynthetic ceiling- climate change- population problems
8. The most important thing to avoid collapse is to keep our minds on the collapse 24/7 it's the most imporant thing in our lifes and forgetting about them won't stop the pollution it's a problem we need to solve.
9. A non sustanible course is a dangerous one because it's in the name. It can't last what happens 50-60 years from now, what do we do? If we solve the problem of pollution what will we do for our children that inherrit the arid dustbowl that we will create if we don't stop the pollution.
10.Jared Diamond is doubtful for the future because he has seen the path we are on. He see's the problems we are suffering from and we have not put more emphasis on it. We will collapse like Easter island, Rome, and anasazi
QURAY CLARKE
1.Montana fails Jared Diamond's 5 point framework , toxic problems and forest management.
ReplyDelete2.The first common thread was they think they are successful.
3.They both are similar because they both create problems.
4.the second common thread is environmental problems.
5.the third common thread was their thinking.
6. The generalization that create blueprint for trouble was their hard time for decision mAking.
7.Water,soil,climate change,population issues and species.
8. I disagree because once if collapse happens everything gets damage and we can fix it if we work hard by getting together.
9. Because it takes time to sove problems and sometimes it doesn't work
10.He's a doubtful because not every time a persons thinking toward anything
AMANI SHARPER
(EMERSON)
1. Montana fails Jared Diamond's 5 point framework.
ReplyDelete2. According to Jared Diamond, the first common thread that emerges from the collapses of past and present societies is the repetity of collapse after a society reaches its peak.
3. The similarities between collapses and bacteria in a petri dish are its consumption and resources.
4. According to Jared Diamond, the second common thread that emerges from the collapses of past and present societies is environmental problems.
5. According to Jared Diamond, the third common thread that emerges from the collapses of past and present societies is civilizations not knowing what they were doing.
6. According to Jared Diamond, generalizations that create a blueprint for trouble are the conflict of interest between the short term and long term in the societies health.
7. 5 ticking time bombs we face today are water, climate change, soil, pollution, and invasive species.
8. According to Jared Diamond, the most important thing we need to do to avoid a collapse is to solve our problems equally. I agree because if we only focus on fixing one problem the other problem may get worse and we'll end up collapsing anyway.
9. A non-sustainable is course a dangerous one because of the amount of time it'll consume in order to maintain.
10. Jared Diamond is hopeful for the future. I think he's hopeful because hes trying to inform people what they can do in order to save the future. Of he was doubtful he wouldn't waste his time trying to make up ways to prevent a collapse from happening to our nation.
1. Montana fails all of Jared Diamond's 5 point frameworks which were: ~Human Environmental Impacts: toxic problems from mine waste, weeds we control, lost agricultural area salinization and forest fires. ~Climate Change: Montana is getting warmer and dryer, irrigation agriculture. ~Relation with Friendly's: Montana's income is dried from outer state, making it vulnerable.
ReplyDelete~Hostile Neighbors: hostiles overseas are affecting oil supply and terrorist attacks.
~Political, Economic, Social Cultural: Montana has long held values which seems to be getting in their way today, long held devotions and had no government regulation.
2. The common thread that emergers from collapses of the past are a cycle of the civlization reaching it's peak then falling from there on out. They build richer and stronger but eventually fall.
3. The similarities between collapses and bacteria in a petri dish is they mismatch and don't belong. Unavailable resources economic problems.
4. Many environmental factors contribute to the collapse of nations, it's the second common thread brought up for example the eastern island and it's use of the tress.
5.According to Jared Diamond, the third common thread that emerges from the collapses of past and present societies is that the civilizations did not know what they were doing and they did not perceive the impacts on the environment or stopped it in time.
6. Jared Diamond generalizations that create a blueprint for trouble are: a conflict of interest between the short term interest of the decision making elites and the long term interest of the society as a whole.
7. Soil,water and climate change
8. the most important thing we need to do to avoid a collapse is to forget about there being any single thing that is the most important thing we need to do. One example is if we solve our problems of water, soil and population but don't solve our problems of toxins then we are in major trouble.
9. A non-sustainable is course a dangerous one because of the amount of time it'll consume in order to maintain
10. Jared Diamond is hopeful for the future. He's hopeful because he is doing everything from making blueprints coming with ideas and spreading this thought and ideas.
1. Montana fails Jared Diamonds 5 point framework due to toxic problems from mine waste that have caused damage of billions of dollars, the loss of agricultural areas and climate change.
ReplyDelete2.
The first common thread that emerges from collapses of past and present societies is are a cycle of civilizations reaching their peaks and then collapsing.
3. The similarities between collapses and bacteria in a petri dish are that collapses are likely when there is a mismatch with available resources and resource consumption. In a petri dish bacteria grow and grow and food disappears until there’s no more food and the bacteria collapses.
4. The second common thread that emerges from the collapses of past and present societies is environmental problems. People destroyed their forests.
5. The third common thread that emerges from the collapses of past and present societies is that people didn’t realize what they were doing to themselves.
6. According to Jared Diamond, where there is a conflict of interest between long term interest and short term interest there is a blueprint for trouble.
7. Five ticking time bombs we face today are water, soil, climate change, toxins, and pollution problems.
8. According to Jared Diamond, the most important thing we need to do to avoid a collapse is think about what we need to do as a whole. If we do something about water and soil but don’t solve population problems then nothing gets solved.
9. A non-sustainable course is a dangerous one because it cannot be maintained.
10. I feel that Jared Diamond is hopeful for the future. He feels that we as a society have caused our own problems, but we can also fix the problems. He feels that there is a lot that we do not understand that we need to understand. He feels that all of the major threats that we face today are caused by our own doing.
1. Deforestation, climate change, mines, human harm.
ReplyDelete2. The first common thread of a collapse is that a society thinks they're invincible.
3. The similarities are the the problems spread quickly without a solution.
4. The second common thread of a collapse is environmental problems.
5. The third thread is that the people don't know how much harm they do to themselves.
6. The blueprint is like a prediction of what will happen in their future.
7. 5 ticking bombs we deal with today are water, soil, climate change, deforestation, and toxics.
8. We need to even out our problems and solve them almost simultaneously because if we don't there won't be a balance and that will lead to worse problems.
9. Non-sustainable course is dangerous because it's solved by wars.
10. Jared diamond is doubtful for the future because he sees all the problems we have today and he doesn't think we are worried enough to solve them which will lead to our collapse.
1. its Deforestation, climate change, mines, human harm.
ReplyDelete2. that a society thinks they're invincible.
3. the problems spread quickly without a solution.
4. second common thread of a collapse is environmental problems.
5. third thread is that the people don't know how much harm they do to themselves.
6. The blueprint is like a prediction of what will happen in their future.
7. the five ticking bombs we deal with today are water, soil, climate change, deforestation, and toxics.
8. We need to even out our problems and solve them almost stimulations because if we don't there won't be a balance and that will lead to worse problems.
9. its not steady course is dangerous because it's solved by wars.
10. Jared diamond is doubtful for the future because he sees all the problems we have today and he doesn't think we are worried enough to solve them which will lead to our collapse however the fact that he is forgetting is that we always rise up and overcome all challenges that come our way.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete1.Montana fails Jared Diamond's 5 point framework , toxic problems and forest management.
ReplyDelete2.The first common thread was they think they are successful.
3.They both are similar because they both create problems.
4.the second common thread is environmental problems.
5.the third common thread was their thinking.
6. The generalization that create blueprint for trouble was their hard time for decision mAking.
7.Water,soil,climate change,population issues and species.
8. I disagree because once if collapse happens everything gets damage and we can fix it if we work hard by getting together.
9. Because it takes time to sove problems and sometimes it doesn't work.
10.He's a doubtful because not every time a persons thinking toward anything.
Montana fails Jared Diamond's 5 point framework, due to mine waste & forest fires
ReplyDelete2. According to Jared Diamond, the collapses of past and present societies is that societies think they're invincible after they hit their peak.
3. consumption and resources.
4. the second common thread that emerges from the collapses of past and present societies is environmental problems.
5. the third common thread that emerges from the collapses of past and present societies is civilizations not knowing what they were doing.
6. generalizations that cause trouble are the conflict of interest between the short term and long term in the societies health.
7. 5 ticking time bombs we face today are water, soil problems climate change & invasive species.
8. the important thing we need to do to avoid a collapse is to solve our problems equally.
9. A non-sustainable is dangerous because of the amount of time it'll consume in order to maintain.
10. Jared Diamond is hopeful for the future. Because societies are slowly learning from the fault of others
1- He had failed the 5 points because of all the bad things that had happen such as Forest Fires, Climate Change, Mines, and Human harm
ReplyDelete2-According Jared Diamond the first common thread that emerges from the collapses of past and present societies is after their peaks because resources and economics.
3-The similarities are the the problems spread quickly without a solution.
4-the second common thread they had was the damages.
5- According to Jared Diamond, the third common thread that emerges from the collapses of past and present societies is that the civilizations did not know.
6-Jareds blueprint for collapse is that a conflic of interest between short term and the long term of the societies health.
7-Water,soil,climate change,population issues and species.
8-According to Jared Diamond, the most important thing we need to do to avoid a collapse is to solve our problems equally. I agree because if we only focus on fixing one problem.
9-A non-sustainable is course a dangerous one because of the amount of time it'll consume in order to maintain.
10- He is a hard working man who don't give up
1. he failed the 5 points because of climate change, human environmental impact and toxic problems
ReplyDelete2.The repeatability of collapse after a society reaches its peak. After the society gets rich and good they collapse after.
3. The similarities between collapses and bacteria in a petri dish mismatch between resources and consumption. Bacteria dish grows and doubles the size and keeps doubling until the highest it dies.
4. According to Jared Diamond, the second common thread that emerges from the collapses of past and present societies is environmental problems.
5. The third common thread that emerges from the collapses of the past and present socieites is the lack of foresight for actions commited. Not seeing the long term cause of their actions
6. The generalization that create blueprint for trouble was their hard time for decision making.
7. Ticking time bombs we face Water pollution -invasive species-photosynthetic ceiling- climate change- population problems
8. The most important thing to avoid collapse is to keep our minds on the collapse 24/7 it's the most imporant thing in our lifes and forgetting about them won't stop the pollution it's a problem we need to solve.
9. A non-sustainable is course a dangerous one because of the amount of time it'll consume in order to maintain.
1- Human environmental impact, toxic problems from mines waste, caused damage in billions of damage, weeds control, 200 mil. a year, forest management, forest fires, climate change friendly trade neighbors, hostile neighbors.
ReplyDelete2- The repeatability of collapse after a society reaches its peak. After the society gets rich and good they collapse after.
3- A mismatch between available resources and resource consumption or economic out plays and economic potential, in a petri dish bacteria grows generations pass and the petri dish degrades.
4- The second common trend that emerges is there are many environment factors that make some societies for fragile than others.
5- The3 third and final trend is that civilizations did not realize what they were doing.
6. generalizations created a blueprint for trouble because there were a lot of decisions between those generalizations short term making decisions.
7.The time bombs we are facing today are water and soil and climate changes.including
Population problems.
8.We need to help our problems by gathering water and soil and to help our population.
9.It can not and would not be maintained until a few years.
10. Yeas i do think hes helpful because he's explains in details that the environmental problems should be protected and good enough for the future to become and better future.we as a nation she listen to him because of his good ted talks videos he has put up to let people know that the world needs to become a better place in order to make the future a better place for the future.i do agree with him because we should listen to what he says,it would help the people understand the good talks he had given us.
Jordan Jerome
1. He had failed the 5 points because of all the bad things that had happen such as Forest Fires, Climate Change, Mines, and Human harm
ReplyDelete2. The first common thread of collapse is at its all time high they are know to collapse
3. Similarities between the collapse was that They both got mixed up with there resources and there economic situation was a mess
4. The second common thing that they had in common was they had many problems with the environment.
5. The third common trend was that they didnt realize how much harm they were doing
6. The blue print for trouble is the short term and the long term and seeing what is going to happen to them
7. 5 Ticking time bombs are soil,water,climate change, pollution and invasive species
8. We need to have all the right resources and enough of it so we dont run out of it and we have extra to prevent us from failing
9. Its dangerous because of the time that it would take to solve all of the problems
10. He is hopeful for the future because what he is planning sounds like a plan that will not fail , its a plan that if we continue to use in the right way its very rare that we can fail.
- Shemar Joachim